Nancy Einhart: She's an Overnight Sensation After 25 Years

Today I'm engaging in shameless self-promotion and answering my own Fan Mail questionnaire.

Nancy Einhart: She's an Overnight Sensation After 25 Years

I’ve got some big news! Today, I’m announcing the winner of the Mundane Mayhem one-year anniversary DBT Vinyl Giveaway!

Please join me in congratulating Josh G., a long-time Drive-By Truckers fan and first-time DBT vinyl owner! Josh, I’m so grateful to have you among my readers.

To the rest of y’all: thank you so much for entering the giveaway. I loved reading everyone’s comments. In fact, the giveaway was so much fun, I think I’ll do another one next year, so don’t go anywhere. 

I didn’t make it to Homecoming West, but I’ve loved seeing everyone’s photos and recaps online. I celebrated my 48th birthday on Friday, November 13, and attended a family wedding, which was a great way to celebrate, given how much I enjoy an open bar and cake. I’m keeping the celebration going today by engaging in shameless self-promotion and answering my own Fan Mail questionnaire.

If you’re interested in being featured in a future edition of Fan Mail, please email me at nancy@mundane-mayhem.com. 

Nancy Einhart, hard at work on Mundane Mayhem.

The basics:

I’m Nancy Einhart, a 48-year-old freelance editor, writer, and the creator of Mundane Mayhem. I was born in Alabama, grew up in Pensacola, FL, and live in Brooklyn, NY, with my rescue dog, Mabel, and my husband, Josh.

How and when did you discover Drive-By Truckers? 

I’ve been a DBT fan since 2003, and I still wish I’d discovered them sooner. The year Decoration Day came out, I was two years out of college and one year into my first real journalism job. As an occasional music writer and music fan about town, I’d heard about Drive-By Truckers and especially about Southern Rock Opera. But at that moment in my life, I’d moved to San Francisco from Chicago and felt eager to escape my Southern accent and my Florida panhandle upbringing, so I resisted.

In 2003, I came to my senses and bought Decoration Day on a whim, after trading a bunch of CDs at Amoeba Music. Listening to it felt like discovering my favorite band in real time.

Nancy and her dog Mabel in the backyard.

What was the album or song that got you into the band?

I bought Decoration Day on CD, which means the first DBT song I ever heard was “The Deeper In.” I remember standing in front of my kitchen boombox and thinking, damn, bold choice for a first track. Opening your album with a song about incest — inspired by a real-life tragedy and delivered with deep empathy — feels like the musical equivalent of organic chemistry. It’s designed to be challenging and weed out the weak.

“The Deeper In” is not the gateway DBT song you’d put on a mixtape. It’s one of the least-appreciated songs on a truly great album.

Shortly after my introduction to the band, I also transformed my mom into a superfan. 

Old Enough to Know Better
Everything about "The Deeper In" makes me a little uncomfortable.

How many shows have you attended? What are your top 1-2 and why? 

I have attended 52 Drive-By Truckers concerts, plus three Cooley solo concerts and one Patterson Hood solo show. 

I’m not really a setlist person. The shows that stand out to me are the ones at very special venues. I was lucky enough to see DBT nine times at The Fillmore in San Francisco, which is one of my favorite places to see live music. One Fillmore show that stands out is May 8, 2009, because I got to go with my mom the day before Mother’s Day. I’m also a huge Hold Steady fan, so the two nights of the Rock and Roll Means Well Tour I saw at the Fillmore (Nov. 23 and Nov. 24, 2008) were also very special.

In 2019, my mom and I attended two DBT shows at the historical Gruene Hall in New Braunfels, TX, and I remember both of those shows very fondly. We got to meet the band before the show. My mom said “y'all are like the boys I used to date.” And Cooley said, “Used to?” That was delightful.

Nan Einhart: It’s Fucking Great to Be Alive
Why "Women Without Whiskey" is her all-time favorite song.

I also maintain that the first DBT show I ever saw (Feb. 15, 2004,) was one of the best. Never again would I see them in such a tiny venue — San Francisco’s Bottom of the Hill held about 250 people. They charged through a truly glorious setlist that night. Mike Cooley sang “Daddy’s Cup.” Jason Isbell sang “Danko/Manuel” off the not-yet-released The Dirty South. Patterson Hood sang “The Night G.G. Allin Came to Town.” They covered “Hey Ya!” by Outkast; Jason nailed the lead vocals. But the performance that really stuck with me was Cooley’s “Panties in Your Purse,” which I heard for the first time that night. 

He Got a Lawyer, You Got a Bottle
“Panties in Your Purse” and the truly glorious setlist from my first DBT show in 2004.

My most disappointing DBT show was when they were supposed to play at Pensacola’s SpringFest music festival, and they had car trouble or something and didn’t show up. I think that was in 2003. 

What DBT song do you think you’ve listened to more than any other and why?

Probably “Zip City” or “Women Without Whiskey.” The lyrics and the sense of yearning expressed in “Zip City” feel so nostalgic to me. And I never get sick of “Women Without Whiskey,” which reminds me of my Uncle Johnny and my mom; it’s her favorite song and was also her ring tone for many years.

Maybe You're Just a Destination
“Zip City” barrels toward its ending like the narrator’s fuel-inefficient car.

Any song you’ve never heard performed live and still hope you do?

Like I said, I’m not really a setlist person, so I can’t be certain which songs I have never heard. But I definitely haven’t heard enough of the songs from Welcome to Club XIII or The New OK.

What underappreciated DBT song do you like?

I really love “Once They Banned Imagine,” and I don’t think I’ve ever heard that one live.

The recording of Nancy's first Drive-By Truckers show (Feb. 15, 2004).

What’s your Lynyrd Skynyrd – aka a band you wish you’d seen live but didn’t?

I am a huge David Bowie fan, but by the time I discovered him freshman year of college, he wasn’t touring very much and I wasn’t in a place where I could chase a tour. I regret not making more of an effort. 

I also really love Silver Jews, so I was very excited to see David Berman perform as Purple Mountains at Hopscotch Festival in 2019, but he died the month before the show. It was still a great festival.

One artist I feel very grateful to have seen before he died is Charles Bradley. He performed at Brooklyn Bowl in 2017, and I went with my husband and mother-in-law, and it was fucking incredible. I think he did three wardrobe changes and left it all on the stage. He died a few months later. I’m so glad I got to see him perform and that I got to experience it with my mother-in-law, who died in 2021.

What’s your favorite piece of DBT merch or memorabilia that you own?

I have a burned CD of my first-ever Drive-By Truckers show, which is still cool even though I can listen to the show online any time I want.

I have a few pieces of original art, including a caricature drawing of Patterson and Cooley that my mom commissioned from a friend. My mom has also made some funny pieces of collage art dedicated to our mutual crush on Mike Cooley.

I also have two posters from DBT shows at The Fillmore in San Francisco, which are really special to me. The Fillmore famously commissions original artwork for many of their shows and hands out free posters at the end of concerts. 

What’s the most DBT superfan thing about you?

Probably the fact that I have a newsletter dedicated to Drive-By Truckers. 

What is your favorite DBT song to sing along with?

“Made Up English Oceans,” because I felt compelled to learn how to sing every word at Cooley speed, and I now I fucking nail it.

Recommendations! Are there any recent records, books, or movies you’ve consumed that you want to recommend to other DBT fans?

This year, I made New Year’s resolutions to listen to more new music and go to more concerts. I didn’t expand my listening habits as much as I’d planned, but I did see some great shows, including David Byrne at an outdoor amphitheater in San Diego during the lunar eclipse, Sleater-Kinney and Liz Phair at Prospect Park Bandshell, Thomas Dollbaum at Union Pool, and Animal Collective playing Feels in its entirety at Knockdown Center.

Some recent, new-to-me musical discoveries include Jeff Rosenstock (thanks to Ben Keefe), the Opal Foxx Quartet (thanks to Matt Etgen), Jesse Welles, and Twisted Teens, plus the new albums from Mountain Goats, Johnny Blue Skies, Leon Bridges, and Alabama Shakes. And for some reason, this was the year that Old 97s finally clicked with me. Speaking of albums, I had forgotten how outstanding Exile in Guyville is, and I spent a lot of time recently with a playlist my friend Miranda made, called Between the Exiles, which mashes up the Liz Phair album with Exile on Main Street.

As for movies, no one needs another endorsement of You Can See Everything, but I do recommend it, as well as Ali G: Who Iz I?

Book-wise, I’ll take this opportunity to recommend my favorite music-related books, including How Music Works by David Byrne, Here, There and Everywhere: My Life Recording the Music of the Beatles by Geoff Emerick, and On Bowie by Rob Sheffield, which is a really heartfelt tribute written from the POV of a fan.

Nancy, at one of her favorite dive bars, The Sandshaker, next to a framed article she wrote.

What have you written this year beside Mundane Mayhem? 

My favorite (not Mundane Mayhem-related) story I wrote this year is 50 Years of Vision: How Alice O’Leary Randall Became the Keeper of the Medical Cannabis Story. It’s an interview with the widow of Robert Randall, who became the first legal medical marijuana patient in America in 1976.

Do you have a favorite dive bar?

I love dive bars, and I promise that one day, I will publish a list of my favorite dive bars in America. But a few of my favorites include:

  • In the Florida panhandle (a great dive-bar region): the Flora-Bama, a legendary beach bar on the border of Florida and Alabama; The Azalea Cocktail Lounge (aka, the Z) in Pensacola, FL; and The Sandshaker on Pensacola Beach, which has a carpeted ceiling and a framed photo on the wall of an article I wrote.
  • In New Orleans, Parasol’s (amazing po’boys) and R Bar.
  • In Miami, it used to be Mac’s Club Deuce, but on a recent visit, I realized one thing I liked about Mac’s is that you could smoke in there, and now that I don't smoke, I can hardly stand being in there.
Drive-By Truckers Songs That Sound Like a Dive Bar
While the Truckers only have a few lyrics that explicitly reference bars, they do have songs that capture the dive bar’s essence.
  • In New York: Bar 169, Jimmy’s Corner, and Nancy Whiskey (where you get a free drink if your name is Nancy).
  • In Chicago, Rossi’s and Carol's Pub.
  • In San Francisco, the 500 Club, Zeitgeist, and Molotov’s, where I once saw a dog sitting on a barstool. 
  • In Portland, the Reel M Inn, where I once saw a human fall off a barstool at 4 p.m.
If you're interested in being featured in a future edition of Fan Mail, email me at nancy@mundane-mayhem.com.